Carney Hospital Redevelopment | Dorchester

12345

Active Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2007
Messages
625
Reaction score
608
O’Brien, who briefed The Reporter about the broad outlines of HYM’s involvement last week, said that the mix of uses on the site will likely include a health care delivery component of some kind along with housing and open space and indicated that the buildings now the site will likely be demolished.

 
The concept includes a 350,000-square-foot healthcare facility on the footprint of the former emergency department, a potential 150,000-square-foot educational building such as a nursing school or training center, approximately 500 new housing units including 200 senior and assisted-living residences and 300 family rental units, new open space connecting to the 27-acre Dorchester Park
 
The loss of Carney was and remains a completely inexcusable catastrophe for the neighborhood, and the fact that the state can’t get its act together to rectify this would be mind blowing were Massachusetts not one of the most corrupt and ineffective governments in the country. No, it’s not “too complicated”; this is an issue that had a solution and the state didn’t want to cough up the money for it. Now, the closest hospitals are Milton and Faulkner—far and more importantly completely inaccessible by transit compared to Carney. Funny that St E’s gets saved and Carney doesn’t?
 
The loss of Carney was and remains a completely inexcusable catastrophe for the neighborhood, and the fact that the state can’t get its act together to rectify this would be mind blowing were Massachusetts not one of the most corrupt and ineffective governments in the country. No, it’s not “too complicated”; this is an issue that had a solution and the state didn’t want to cough up the money for it. Now, the closest hospitals are Milton and Faulkner—far and more importantly completely inaccessible by transit compared to Carney. Funny that St E’s gets saved and Carney doesn’t?
I lost my hospital too in that Steward meltdown, and it's a major sore spot for me, but don't you think you might be projecting prior spite for MA onto this situation? It's not the Commonwealth's job to bail out crooked healthcare companies, particularly to save hospitals that cost way more to run than they could hope to make. MA population may be aging (more hospitalizations), but lacking immigration we'll begin shrinking very soon, and then these hospitals will be even less financially workable.
 
500 units of housing, a new ER, and a bigger Dot Park is all good. It would be fantastic if they could partner with Laboure College in Milton. They have a great nursing program that used to be at the Carney.
 
I lost my hospital too in that Steward meltdown, and it's a major sore spot for me, but don't you think you might be projecting prior spite for MA onto this situation? It's not the Commonwealth's job to bail out crooked healthcare companies, particularly to save hospitals that cost way more to run than they could hope to make. MA population may be aging (more hospitalizations), but lacking immigration we'll begin shrinking very soon, and then these hospitals will be even less financially workable.
I like to think of it this way: I'll assume that a lot of us here play games like Sim City, Cities Skylines, etc. When residents are sick, do you zone commercial and hope that a company builds a hospital or do you plop and maintain one as a government cost?

[for those that don't play, the latter is the only option]
 
The loss of Carney was and remains a completely inexcusable catastrophe for the neighborhood, and the fact that the state can’t get its act together to rectify this would be mind blowing were Massachusetts not one of the most corrupt and ineffective governments in the country.
There are some issues at the state level sure, but this is utter nonsense. Continuously named one of the best states to live in year after year. Doesn’t get that way all on its own
 
I lost my hospital too in that Steward meltdown, and it's a major sore spot for me, but don't you think you might be projecting prior spite for MA onto this situation? It's not the Commonwealth's job to bail out crooked healthcare companies, particularly to save hospitals that cost way more to run than they could hope to make. MA population may be aging (more hospitalizations), but lacking immigration we'll begin shrinking very soon, and then these hospitals will be even less financially workable.
“Expensive to run” in hospital speak just means that it mostly served poor people. Figuring out a solution is the job of the leadership of this state. The fact that it’s difficult, complicated, challenging, or expensive doesn’t change the fact, it only highlights the unacceptability of the failure.


There are some issues at the state level sure, but this is utter nonsense. Continuously named one of the best states to live in year after year. Doesn’t get that way all on its own
See above. The richness of this state and its coffers makes this all the more egregious. To say that Massachusetts of all places can’t afford to fix this and do right by patients is egregious beyond belief. It would at least be expected if this were Mississippi.
 
Senator Nick Collins, a member of the Joint Committee on Ways and Means, this week voted to advance Senate consideration of the BRIGHT Act, a major higher education infrastructure bill, while filing an amendment aimed at building a new facility for UMass Boston’s nursing program on the Columbia Point campus, as well as a potential satellite campus on the former Carney Hospital site in Dorchester.
 

Back
Top