Portland Music Hall | Cumberland Avenue

Portlander

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2010
Messages
2,599
Reaction score
5,635
Started a separate thread for the potential Portland Music Hall which if approved is expected to start construction in the fall of 2025 and open in 2027. Props to Max for initially announcing the project in the Herald Square post. (y)
Screenshot 2024-12-23 at 2.51.46 PM 2.png

Mainebiz article
 
Last edited:
Screenshot 2024-12-23 at 2.35.04 PM.png

Some images of Boston's MGM Music Hall Fenway which is an example of what Portland's venue will be modeled after with a smaller capacity. Photo Credits: McNamara-Salvia
 
Last edited:
I read all the comments over the past days in the PPH, WGME, etc. both for and against this project. You have people pushing for affordable housing, well, that's good, but why don't you buy the parcel and develop it with your own money I say. Then you have others that it's a travesty to build it next to City Hall/Merrill. No one was around when Congress Street was lined with Theatres, all with different shows, layouts, etc. Merrill is a different animal compared to this. I know, I work over there and its crumbling aka the ceiling, the lift out back is falling apart and is a needle hangout. The apartment building across the street from the loading dock is a heroin hangout. Plus, a recent murder happened there. The City has no money or refuses to fund the hall. It's perfect for the symphony and the organ. It's hard to put on a big Broadway show due to the constraints. Unless the City upgrades the loading area, acts are going to go somewhere else because it's getting a bad reputation. The same goes for CCCC and the State Theatre. A large donor was going to donate money to fix the issue with the thrust that has to be manually built several times a year that costs 10s of thousands a year. The Merrill comm said no. Again, politics rise amuck next door. Build this correctly, and they will come..
 
I read all the comments over the past days in the PPH, WGME, etc. both for and against this project. You have people pushing for affordable housing, well, that's good, but why don't you buy the parcel and develop it with your own money I say. Then you have others that it's a travesty to build it next to City Hall/Merrill. No one was around when Congress Street was lined with Theatres, all with different shows, layouts, etc. Merrill is a different animal compared to this. I know, I work over there and its crumbling aka the ceiling, the lift out back is falling apart and is a needle hangout. The apartment building across the street from the loading dock is a heroin hangout. Plus, a recent murder happened there. The City has no money or refuses to fund the hall. It's perfect for the symphony and the organ. It's hard to put on a big Broadway show due to the constraints. Unless the City upgrades the loading area, acts are going to go somewhere else because it's getting a bad reputation. The same goes for CCCC and the State Theatre. A large donor was going to donate money to fix the issue with the thrust that has to be manually built several times a year that costs 10s of thousands a year. The Merrill comm said no. Again, politics rise amuck next door. Build this correctly, and they will come..
I know if you look up at the ceiling of the Merrill, the paint looks as bad as it did before the massive renovation. Granted, I have no idea what it would take to repaint it giving the height, but it still looks bad. I have no insight on the loading dock (and my memories of the Congress St. area having multiple theaters all have them showing porn) but I'll take your word for it.
 
This venue will be a game changer for greater Portland's music scene and is a totally different animal than the Merrill as you have pointed out PWMFlyer. The capacity will draw concerts and shows in a more intimate setting that does not require the 8000 seats in the Cross Arena but needs more than the 1000 seats in the Aura, 1800 seats in the State and 1900 in the Merrill. Promoters and artists have stated in a poll done several years ago that a 3000-5000 capacity venue is the sweet spot for concerts and touring productions. As an attendee to well over 100 concerts in my adult life, I'm done with the 12,000 + seat outdoor venues, stadiums and mega arenas. Sound quality, sight lines, distance from the stage and manageable wait times for restrooms and food are now a much higher priority.
 
I know if you look up at the ceiling of the Merrill, the paint looks as bad as it did before the massive renovation. Granted, I have no idea what it would take to repaint it giving the height, but it still looks bad.
My former girlfriend and I went to see the Beach Boys (Mike Love and his cover band) and Air Supply (hardest working duo in the music business) a few years ago and I noticed the early signs of wear and tear since the last renovation in 1997. Hopefully the supporters of the Portland Symphony and the loyal Merrill Auditorium donors will start a campaign to address the conditions in the future before they get out of hand.
 
Here are 4 key things to draw big music acts....
1. more profits with merch and food and drink
2. good acoustics
3. a rad and perhaps epic space for the artist's dressing room (you have no idea)
4. no rank odors (older places like the State Theatre and Merrill)

ALL Maine venues fail miserably with at least 3 of these. If CIA did number 3 with a space on top of the building with great views and a comfy interior design, that would work. Number 2 could be done with overhead acoustic panels. And number 1 is also possible with knocking down some walls and perhaps making the NW roof corner exterior into a massive bar with giant screens and comfortable seats at tables and bars. Taylor Swift last year made 800K on one particular cocktail offering at NRG in Houston. Live Nation wants a new venue (their own) so that they can make profits on the food and drink too. Eating and drinking is a much bigger deal today. What's the obesity rate now?

Oh, and it's not the seats. I went to a Bruins game last night at TD Garden and sat in a more expensive loge seat and I'm not a big guy. It's considerably less seat and leg room than CIA.
 

Back
Top