[ARCHIVED] Harbor Garage Redevelopment | 70 East India Row | Waterfront | Downtown

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

I want to see the waterfront from the greenway, I don't want my vision blocked by a massive structure. If built, the character of the area transforms from nearly quaint and welcoming to imposing and more isolating. A visitor's awareness will always be partially diverted from the water to the towering presence of the tall buildings. Yes, I want to be in the sun when viewing the beautiful scenery later in the day and not have a shadow cast over me and the area around me.

Quaint? Welcoming? See through??? m, have you ever been there? It is currently a hulking parking garage and has been your whole adult life.
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

I am adamantly against this project, it will utterly ruin the beautiful ambiance that exists on the waterfront. The huge girth of the buildings is obscene for such a delicate part of the city. I want to see the waterfront from the greenway, I don't want my vision blocked by a massive structure. If built, the character of the area transforms from nearly quaint and welcoming to imposing and more isolating. A visitor's awareness will always be partially diverted from the water to the towering presence of the tall buildings. Yes, I want to be in the sun when viewing the beautiful scenery later in the day and not have a shadow cast over me and the area around me.

The best way to tell if you have taken a loony position is when the rest of the board starts siding with TheRifleman.

As others have said, I guess you must not have noticed that the space is currently occupied by a concrete GARAGE.
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

Ha, quaint. Good one. But seriously, you know what is truly quaint? PO Square. 'Nuff said.
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

If Mayor Walsh approves, his urban vision is uninformed and I will assume that he is partly pandering to his construction union buddies.

Yeah, his vision is "urban". You are correct. I'll give you a mulligan on the last part of that sentence.
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

Yes, I want to be in the sun when viewing the beautiful scenery later in the day and not have a shadow cast over me and the area around me.

Ah yes, that beautiful 1 block stretch of the harbor walk that is already in the shadows due to the 8 story garage? You do realize that the sun sets in the west, casting shadows in the east?
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

I am adamantly against this project, it will utterly ruin the beautiful ambiance that exists on the waterfront. The huge girth of the buildings is obscene for such a delicate part of the city. I want to see the waterfront from the greenway, I don't want my vision blocked by a massive structure. If built, the character of the area transforms from nearly quaint and welcoming to imposing and more isolating. A visitor's awareness will always be partially diverted from the water to the towering presence of the tall buildings. Yes, I want to be in the sun when viewing the beautiful scenery later in the day and not have a shadow cast over me and the area around me.

Just because a developer buys property it doesn't entitle him to put up whatever he wants. Commerce of this scale has its place, it isn't here. If the waterfront guidelines allow this, I've lost faith in the process. If Vivien Lee accepts this project, I've lost trust in her. If Mayor Walsh approves, his urban vision is uninformed and I will assume that he is partly pandering to his construction union buddies.

Is this a joke?

 
Last edited:
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

Thanks for the live reportage. It is sincerely appreciated.

To draw North America to this location I think they're going have something more unique than four seasons, which, as I understand them, are quite widespread.

How about an ice rink/track AROUND one of the buildings? Now THAT would be iconic!
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

I am adamantly against this project, it will utterly ruin the beautiful ambiance that exists on the waterfront. The huge girth of the buildings is obscene for such a delicate part of the city. I want to see the waterfront from the greenway, I don't want my vision blocked by a massive structure. If built, the character of the area transforms from nearly quaint and welcoming to imposing and more isolating. A visitor's awareness will always be partially diverted from the water to the towering presence of the tall buildings. Yes, I want to be in the sun when viewing the beautiful scenery later in the day and not have a shadow cast over me and the area around me.

Just because a developer buys property it doesn't entitle him to put up whatever he wants. Commerce of this scale has its place, it isn't here. If the waterfront guidelines allow this, I've lost faith in the process. If Vivien Lee accepts this project, I've lost trust in her. If Mayor Walsh approves, his urban vision is uninformed and I will assume that he is partly pandering to his construction union buddies.

".....and the 2014 Batshit Crazy Post Award goes to ......EdMc, for his "Invisible and Quaint Harbor Garage Post!!!!"
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

How about an ice rink/track AROUND one of the buildings? Now THAT would be iconic!

Whatever it is, "four seasons and some glass" isn't it.

To be a true attraction, it doesn't have to be big, but it had better feel unique in "all of North America" which, these days, favors things that are tinged with "weird," like Providence's WaterFire.

At the brainstorming session, if they're going to come up with something "iconic" they'll have to seriously entertain wacky stuff, like
- the first urban "adventure park" that tourists can walk under
(such as the Virginia Aquarium has...its free to walk "under" as people zip-line and tight-rope-walk above you)
- a super-tall climbing wall (recreate a cliff face)
- a linear ice rink (like a Dutch Canal)
- a free Aquarium "outpost" (mammals?)
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

Or maybe it's the Harbor Towers that are supposed to be quaint? I guess you could call brutalism quaint. I guess... Because if it's not the Harbor Towers he's referring to, then it's gotta be the Aquarium (brutalist block with quaint tiny windows) or the Marriot Longwharf (I have no idea what to even call that style. Maybe it's quaint after all?).
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

shmessy - great award!!
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

The award name should be changed to "The Memorial 'You Made Everyone Agree with Rifleman' Award for Achievements in Bat-shittery."
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

I read his post as sarcasm but until he says so, I'm not sure.
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

^^^^^^

I agree, he's just giving us a preview of what some of the more extreme NIMBY arguments will be when the public/neighborhood meetings begin!
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

Stop getting in the way of our NIMBY bashing with your measured responses!
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

The award name should be changed to "The Memorial 'You Made Everyone Agree with Rifleman' Award for Achievements in Bat-shittery."

No, no. It has to be the Ned Flaherty Memorial Award. AKA The Ned.
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

I reviewed EdMc's recent posts. He isn't a nutter. I suspect it's a rather brilliant preview of what we'll no doubt soon hear.
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

Yeah. Though I still like the idea of The Neddy. :)
 
Re: The Boston Arch (Aquarium parking garage)

It doesn't matter what the NIMBYS say. This project is going through the pipeline. This is good for everybody, Tourists, taxpayers and Boston overall.

Walsh wants a Legacy and transforming the GREENWAY into a destination spot will be his legacy.

Chiofaro made his point clear in the Boston Herald Interview that he would be willing to keep the Garage for generations. WHO WOULDN'T at this point. Parking is only going to go up in price. It's all Supply & Demand in the city. There is no parking after Seaport gets built up.

Read it and weep Naysayers & Haters but I'm calling it now CHIOFARO gets the GREENLIGHT.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top