Thanks for 3-day old news. The guy was "unsteady on his feet" (wasted) and it was 1am. The Red Line isn't "haunted." It's a sad and unfortunate event, but get your story straight.
The core three-story art deco headhouse and copper-sheathed platforms *were* built. the 14-story tower wasn't for the reasons you outlined. the crash of '29 didn't immediately impact planning pipelines (and then, obviously, it did). BERy and others wouldn't know that at the time of the proposal...
I don't mind the 2019 proposal at all -- I just take issue with the "tower" nonsense. Also agree that a well-executed art deco tower would be preferable, especially one with a distinctive crown or even a spire (a spire?!?! in Boston??!).
I'm sure whatever they eventually do with this property won't be like the 2019 proposal, but it always astounds me when a 20-story structure would ever be referred to as a "tower." Any other city in the world would just consider a 20-story residential building a... building.
Awnings, non-monochrome signage, actual balconies -- none of this is terribly difficult. These people shat the bed bigtime. If the original iteration of Hotel Commonwealth (aka Hotel Cheesecake Factory) was enough to prompt the city to take action, this stupid "piazza" should be, as well.
I stand (sit) corrected -- as I did a few weeks ago when your points were made by another. *My* point is that the area in between Trinity, the BPL, the hotel, etc. has never historically been a "park" (lush expanses of grass, tons of trees) in any way.
Slowly getting taller and wider with the Western part of the complex nearlhy about to join the Eastern in going vertical. These may not be especially sexy pix (and I can absolutely stop posting pix if it's just coming off as clutter) and the end-result won't be sexy, either, but it's so nice to...