Was there last night and if those cranes hinder the landing of a helicopter, the pilot should not be licensed. There is plenty of clearance between the cranes and the pads.It looks like that crane tower sort of interferes with the flight path of the landing EMS helicopters. But of course, nothing will happen. Pilot error never happens. Impossible.
I recently spent an entire year working on a television pilot on helicopters in NYC. I'm privy to A LOT. What CAN happen is that an EMS pilot from perhaps Boston--in an emergency weather situation--has to fly to Maine Medical and he/she would not know about these cranes because of the sudden nature of the event. Human error in helicopter accidents is how they almost always happen. I was doing this at the time of two fatal crashes. One of these crashes was caused by negligence (or fatigue) from a highly experienced pilot on the rooftop of a building, a few blocks from the heliport (there are no rooftop landings in Manhattan). At Maine Medical, the tops of the cranes are touching a realistic flight path, and from the south or west, potentially a hinderance.Was there last night and if those cranes hinder the landing of a helicopter, the pilot should not be licensed. There is plenty of clearance between the cranes and the pads.
I see the helicopters almost every day and they always approach between Weymouth and Ellsworth Street to land on the helipad.I recently spent an entire year working on a television pilot on helicopters in NYC. I'm privy to A LOT. What CAN happen is that an EMS pilot from perhaps Boston--in an emergency weather situation--has to fly to Maine Medical and he/she would not know about these cranes because of the sudden nature of the event. Human error in helicopter accidents is how they almost always happen. I was doing this at the time of two fatal crashes. One of these crashes was caused by negligence (or fatigue) from a highly experienced pilot on the rooftop of a building, a few blocks from the heliport (there are no rooftop landings in Manhattan). At Maine Medical, the tops of the cranes are touching a realistic flight path, and from the south or west, potentially a hinderance.
Yes, they are all LifeFlight of Maine and they arrive from the north (Lewiston, Augusta, and Bangor, primarily). All of these pilots know exactly what is happening at Maine Medical Center. Others, or pilots from other places, probably do not. That is the point that I am making here. Maine Medical is a top tier hospital now, and it is conceivable that other EMS companies outside of Maine could bring someone from the south or west-to Maine. It is also a hospital that can be used for emergencies by the military. All that I am implying here is that the hospital should be proactive with this type of scenario. And EMS pilots are trained to land on highways, for the obvious of reasons. Roadways are all around us, so the approach to the hospital can be from anywhere. "To err is human, to forgive divine." Alexander Pope (not a pilot).I see the helicopters almost every day and they always approach between Weymouth and Ellsworth Street to land on the helipad.
One must hope that the applicable regulations are being followed, with obstruction lights etc. Human error can always be a factor, especially when doing something as inherently hazardous as piloting a helicopter in a reduced visibility situation, so all that can really be done (aside from not proceeding with the project or shutting down the helipad for the duration, both horrid options) is to ensure that the cranes are in the location they're supposed to be in when not in use to hopefully minimize surprises.I recently spent an entire year working on a television pilot on helicopters in NYC. I'm privy to A LOT. What CAN happen is that an EMS pilot from perhaps Boston--in an emergency weather situation--has to fly to Maine Medical and he/she would not know about these cranes because of the sudden nature of the event. Human error in helicopter accidents is how they almost always happen. I was doing this at the time of two fatal crashes. One of these crashes was caused by negligence (or fatigue) from a highly experienced pilot on the rooftop of a building, a few blocks from the heliport (there are no rooftop landings in Manhattan). At Maine Medical, the tops of the cranes are touching a realistic flight path, and from the south or west, potentially a hinderance.
One must hope that the applicable regulations are being followed, with obstruction lights etc. Human error can always be a factor, especially when doing something as inherently hazardous as piloting a helicopter in a reduced visibility situation, so all that can really be done (aside from not proceeding with the project or shutting down the helipad for the duration, both horrid options) is to ensure that the cranes are in the location they're supposed to be in when not in use to hopefully minimize surprises.
I quoted this post specifically, though, because of the Manhattan heliport statement. Is the one on the MetLife (former PanAm) building at GCT no longer in use? Or were you referring to hospital pads specifically? (Not that I've ever taken a helicopter into NYC, or anywhere for that matter other than a ride at the fair, but I know that heliport existed.)