Filene's Basement in talks to stay downtown
By Jenn Abelson, Globe Staff | February 16, 2007
Filene's Basement is in negotiations to stay in Downtown Crossing by moving into a space vacated last year by bookstore chain Barnes & Noble.
Commonwealth Holding LP, which owns the building on Washington Street, is talking both with Filene's Basement and the developers who are renovating the historic complex where the discount store currently is located. Commonwealth Holding is asking for a 15-year lease at $3.2 million each year for the first five years, according to a local official briefed on the negotiations. Afterward, the rent could increase every five years for the rest of the lease.
Filene's Basement, the Boston icon that birthed discounting, is moving out of its original store by fall to accommodate the massive redevelopment of the building, which previously housed the flagship Filene's department store. Filene's Basement, a separate company , has said it will return to the renovated building in the spring of 2009.
City officials have called on Filene's Basement, one of Boston's top tourist attractions, to find a temporary home in Downtown Crossing. Filene's Basement, which did not return calls seeking comment, previously said it is working with real estate brokers to scout out potential sites.
The negotiations for the former Barnes & Noble site, however, are in a tenuous state because the building's landlord, Robert Posner , is asking for a lease that Filene's Basement and the developers think is too long and too costly, said the local official, who asked not to be named because the talks are ongoing.
Posner last night said he is asking for market rate rents and other potential tenants are being offered the same deal.
He said the space being offered is about 49,000 square feet, which would be about $65 a square foot. The local official said Posner is overestimating the useable space.
A listing sheet for the site says there is about 36,000 square feet available on three floors, according to Annette Born , principal of the retail consulting firm Urban/Born Associates.
Born said the street-level space may be worth $50 to $60 a square foot, but the upper floor and basement would be worth significantly less. A developer of the Filene's site, Gale International, counter-offered with about $15 a square foot, according to Posner. John B. Hynes III, president of Gale, could not be reached for comment.
Filene's Basement is expected to receive $15 million to $20 million to vacate its space while the developer renovates the old Filene's building, according to the local official. Filene's Basement has also looked for temporary quarters at other sites nearby, including the Lafayette Corporate Center and the site of a former Gold's Gym. But the former Barnes & Noble location is the most viable option at this time, the local official said, and City Hall may get involved in the next week to try and to broker a fair deal.
"This is a very important part of Downtown Crossing, historically and for the future," said Dot Joyce , a spokeswoman for Boston Mayor Thomas M. Menino's office.
Jenn Abelson can be reached at
abelson@globe.com.
? Copyright 2007 Globe Newspaper Company.