North Station, Charles River Draw, & Tower A

That list of precluded firms is interesting. There are some big names in there.
 
That list of precluded firms is interesting. There are some big names in there.
1333.jpg
The MBTA's preclusion list, unlike MassDOTs and the states, doesn't imply bad faith or conduct that would be disqualifying of a contractor. Its more that these firms in this particular case know a lot more about this bridge, so are precluded from bidding on it as they have insider knowledge. In this case, STV, HNTB and TRC as a JV had won design and engineering contracts for Draw 1 way back in 2019; those renders we've see of Draw 1 are actually from STV, and their work makes up most of the preliminary stuff complete to date.
 
Wouldn't having extensive knowledge from a previous contract to study the bridge help with designing the replacement bridge, and wouldn't that be desirable? It does give them a (potentially unfair) advantage against other bidders, but precluding firms that did preliminary work from bidding on the subsequent design/build contract seems odd.
 
Wouldn't having extensive knowledge from a previous contract to study the bridge help with designing the replacement bridge, and wouldn't that be desirable? It does give them a (potentially unfair) advantage against other bidders, but precluding firms that did preliminary work from bidding on the subsequent design/build contract seems odd.
An expert could check me on this, but I might guess two things:
1) It was likely known well in advance by STV that by participating in the earlier design contract, they'd be ineligible to be the lead contractor to general manage the whole construction project (and I think chose to participate knowing that) (this might apply to others involved earlier as well), yet
2) I don't think they'd be ineligible for future/continued consulting contracts to the prime contractor. In other words, they are not blocked from contributing their expertise to earn more contract money; they just can't be the prime.
Again, all best guesses...
 
Construction will start this month on the long-awaited replacement of a rail drawbridge that crosses the Charles River outside North Station, a $1.06 billion project that’s scheduled to last through 2032 — all without interrupting train service.
A joint venture led by Swedish construction giant Skanska will replace the two nearly century-old bascule bridges and 1.5 miles of train tracks, along with adding a station platform and two train tracks to the 10 already operating out of North Station.
“By leveraging innovative design and construction solutions, our team will deliver a future-ready rail network while maintaining uninterrupted service for the passengers who rely on it every day,” said Paul Pedini, senior vice president of Skanska USA Civil, in a statement.
The project will also replace the control tower where crews manage 200 daily train trips and access for water traffic on the Charles River beneath the bridge. Some 11 million riders on MBTA Commuter Rail and Amtrak trains pass over the bridges each year.
[...]
There will be “temporary disruptions” to MBTA and Amtrak service on weekends, when train traffic is “less aggressive” than during the work week, said Karl Eckstrom, the MBTA’s deputy chief of structures overseeing the Draw One Bridge replacement project, at a January 2025 hearing on the project.
That will allow operations to maintain a relatively normal pace, “with some of the bridge tracks being constricted during the weekend,” Eckstrom said at that 2025 meeting.
 

Back
Top