Roslindale Infill and Small Developments

FK4
Senior Member

JoinedNov 13, 2012
Messages2,391
Reaction score17
Jun 18, 2019

Thanks Henry. I don't mean to be as acerbic as I sometimes come off as... but having lived in JP for years, there was a very strong sense that the "real" first wavers represented the "real JP" and wanted it preserved the way they liked it. It's a real problem in cities today, and like I said, I can't blame them: they moved in in the '70s and '80s, made it the crunchy, quirky place it is now (or was 15 years ago), and now that's made JP desirable for more soulless, yuppie development that will inevitably erode the neighborhood character. Since most of JP is multifamily homes that were once single family, it isn't that easy to just build more housing without genuinely running the risk of destroying the atmosphere there. And this holds true for all great neighborhoods. It's a complex problem and there aren't simple solutions. Every area must do its part, but the hard truth, I do believe, is we really cannot preserve the classic Boston neighborhood - which is lowrise, quaint, local - and maintain affordability. In the end, it's going to be either "museum neighborhoods" for millionaires, or a substantially more urban and crowded city feel than Boston is hitherto used to. I suppose we shall see.

I highlighted the comment about change and neighborhoods -- kinda like Climate -- there's a reason that the averages to which everything is being compared are 30 year averages -- that's how long people live in a place -- aka a generation

Things change on about that 30 year timetable in neighborhoods as well -- houses get upgraded by new folks older houses fall into disrepair and may be an opportunity for a bulldozer renovation Some houses [typically on busy corners] end up as places for professionals and others to do business

Take a look at nearly every neighborhood in Boston, or Cambridge, or any one of the towns in/on the Rt-128 loop -- the transformation process repeats in varying forms on that 30 year timescale. I doubt that there is any building in the Back Bay, Beacon Hill, or the North End except Churches which were built originally as anything other than single family housing [OK a couple of other exceptions] -- BUT no one built a building in those neighborhoods to house a nice restaurant, or a retail shop or even a doctor's or law office -- they were building houses [sometime at the top of the market such as Beacon Hill toward the Boston Common or Commonwealth Avenue] and [sometimes midmarket such as near Paul Revere's House] -- Houses. Outside of the obvious original commercial districts and some later industrial areas -- all of Boston [and environs inside / on Rt-128] was built originally as single family houses or small multis such as the Legendary 3-Deckers.

It's only when wholesale redevelopment occurred such as after a major fire, [1872 downtown] or when new land appeared after filling that people began to think about building for other uses such as commercial warehouses, factories or shops. A couple of generations go by and the character which we associate a place today becomes established -- but all the while its still changing under our noses.
 
I think there are a lot of competing interests within the Main Street framework, but I don't know that I would describe it as exclusively NIMBY. I agree, though, that we aren't getting any satisfactory information about the sub-station financing. If I had the money, I'd turn it into a brewery/beer garden with live music.

So looks like I nailed it, as it is exactly what ended up happening with that space. Anyway, sorry about the bump, but I'm thinking this thread should probably be merged with the other Rozzie developments thread:

 
So looks like I nailed it, as it is exactly what ended up happening with that space. Anyway, sorry about the bump, but I'm thinking this thread should probably be merged with the other Rozzie developments thread:

Done. If the thread makes for tricky reading post-merge, blame me.
 
No tricky reading, there was no timeline overlap between the two.
 
16 unit condo approved for Taft Hill Terrace in Roslindale Square. This is behind Shanti, and next to the Greater Roslindale Medical & Dental Center, facing the municipal parking lot.
  • Key elements to note:
  • 14 parking spaces (less than zoning requires)
  • bike parking for 16
  • 11 one bed units, 3 two bed, 2 three bed
Write-up at Universal Hub:

Small Project Review Application:

I think this is an interesting building. It's similar to a lot of what is going up in JP or Southie, but the facade is more textured, and somewhat broken up by the inclusion of balconies. Roslindale has so far not seen a lot of this type of construction to date, just a few other buildings, but hopefully this will continue to push in the direction of more housing, at least in the square, which is both a commercial and transit hub.
 

Attachments

  • Rozie1.PNG
    Rozie1.PNG
    643 KB · Views: 245
  • Rozzie2.PNG
    Rozzie2.PNG
    450.9 KB · Views: 190
From Universal Hub:
Board Chairwoman Christine Araujo voted for the variances needed for the proposal, but used it to issue a request to other potential Roslindale developers: Don't propose things that so out of character with the rest of the neighborhood.
Araujo, herself a Roslindale resident, said she was particularly concerned by a rendering showing the building from Basile Street on the other side of Adams Park: "It looks like it could very well be South Boston or Dorchester or anywhere in the universe," rather than something that fits in with Roslindale's existing aesthetic, she said. "It just looks out of context."


If anything this is a considerable upgrade for Rozzie and long overdue. More of this, much more.
 
Looks like wallpaper city has started construction on the two floors of residential above their existing retail space.
 
A good project in my opinion, reasonably attractive, good density upgrade, a small community theater (already exists on the current property), and space for some retail. Expect huge pushback from the community as there are zero included parking spots.
 
A good project in my opinion, reasonably attractive, good density upgrade, a small community theater (already exists on the current property), and space for some retail. Expect huge pushback from the community as there are zero included parking spots.

Isn't that studio ratio kind of high?
 
Isn't that studio ratio kind of high?
I'm not sure. I know that a lot of triple decker units in Roslindale are essentially co-housing. The 3-4 roommates might well prefer to each have their own studio were it available. But instead, they occupy what could be a family residence.
 
I'm not sure. I know that a lot of triple decker units in Roslindale are essentially co-housing. The 3-4 roommates might well prefer to each have their own studio were it available. But instead, they occupy what could be a family residence.
More info on this in the linked presentation. Looks like Roslindale has very little in the way of single bedroom or studio units. The link has that data but also a lot more good information about the 4200 Washington St. project, such as their plan for a minimum of 40% affordable units.

 
More info on this in the linked presentation. Looks like Roslindale has very little in the way of single bedroom or studio units. The link has that data but also a lot more good information about the 4200 Washington St. project, such as their plan for a minimum of 40% affordable units.


At first glance this looks like a bad development for Rozzie, but it does partner with the local businesses and the retail sizes are small and will fit the neighborhood. I like it!
 
I was really impressed by the presentation Arx Urban put together. I think the building will fit well next to the municipal building, which is similar height. It also takes some visual cues from the yellow brick of that building. And the commitment to the existing businesses is great, especially the extent to which the performance space will be improved to become a true theater and community resource. Build it!
 
I was really impressed by the presentation Arx Urban put together. I think the building will fit well next to the municipal building, which is similar height. It also takes some visual cues from the yellow brick of that building. And the commitment to the existing businesses is great, especially the extent to which the performance space will be improved to become a true theater and community resource. Build it!

Agreed--public comments during the meeting were largely supportive too it seemed like
 
It increases density in an underdeveloped yet immensely walkable neighborhood, it's properly scaled, it has a cultural component, and -- miracle of all miracles -- it has more retail spaces that what it's replacing. This is basically the gold standard for outer neighborhood development.
 
An important development that adds much needed density and paves the way for further height in the square revealed its facade this week and, uhhh, god damn it:

D49E2873-FC4C-42AE-A946-EE5FD118705E.jpeg

C83E5E68-765C-46D3-B36D-924471C2B83A.jpeg

Roslindale Square is filled with some truly beautiful old brick buildings, and this hideous, suburban siding spits at all of them. This is arguably the single most prominent site in the whole neighborhood, too.
 

Back
Top