Fall River/New Bedford Commuter Rail (South Coast Rail)

This is what the MBTA page for Middleborough/Lakeville station (to be renamed Lakeville station tomorrow) currently looks like. Shuttle trains to Bridgewater were considered around 2017 when SCR was being reevaluated, but not deemed practical. Yet somehow they got coded into the website!

1742780851985.png
 
Here is the new updated transit map on apple maps in anticipation of the new service tomorrow morning. Been waiting to open apple maps and see this addition show up for years! Its not every day you get to see a major extension added to the map. Seeing glx added to the map and now SCR both within a couple years is amazing. This is a very extensive commuter rail system. Now lets get some electrification!

IMG_2100.jpeg
 
Last edited:
This is what the MBTA page for Middleborough/Lakeville station (to be renamed Lakeville station tomorrow) currently looks like. Shuttle trains to Bridgewater were considered around 2017 when SCR was being reevaluated, but not deemed practical. Yet somehow they got coded into the website!

View attachment 61327
FYI, I wasn't able to find any schedules of a Lakeville-Bridgewater shuttle on either MBTA's website or TransSee (which pulls GTFS data). It's most likely just ghost code.
 
This is incredibly catty of me to say, but I didn’t realize there was direct service from Church Street to Fall River.

Less sarcastically, they seemed to have the convention of showing branches splitting (Stoughton, Rockburyport), so I admit I hope they adjust that on next printing.

More positively: woohoo!! It’s finally open!
 
That's quite the wack Zone progression right there. They got the endpoints right, but the gradations to that point are just awful and in dire need of a reboot.
Middleborough should probably be Zone 7, since there’s an abrupt jump from Zone 6 to 8 without a Zone 7 station. It would make sense to ease fares in Middleborough, considering how Middleborough/Lakeville was controversially closed.
 
Middleborough should probably be Zone 7, since there’s an abrupt jump from Zone 6 to 8 without a Zone 7 station. It would make sense to ease fares in Middleborough, considering how Middleborough/Lakeville was controversially closed.
Not just there. Campello gets hosed being in the same city as Brockton and Montello.

I'd do:
Montello+Brockton+Campello - 4
Bridgewater - 5
Middleboro - 6 (same as fellow 495-sited stops Mansfield, Forge Park, Lowell, and Lawrence)
East Taunton - 7
the branches - 8

They're afraid to do it because it would expose all kinds of other inequities on the system, like Kingston in 8 and the Providence Line skipping from 4 to 6, and so on and so on.

But this is completely bonkers. . .
1742857663500.png
 
Not just there. Campello gets hosed being in the same city as Brockton and Montello.
You’re right, I didn’t even realize that Campello isn’t the same zone as Brockton and Montello. That’s very odd.
They're afraid to do it because it would expose all kinds of other inequities on the system, like Kingston in 8 and the Providence Line skipping from 4 to 6, and so on and so on.
When was the last time the MBTA re-zoned a station? I know that Forge Park went from zone 7 to zone 6 around the time it opened in 1988, but that was 37 years ago…
 
It is good that these cities are finally connected to Boston by rail. I however do not expect to see a large number of daily commuters from either Fall River or New Bedford. It looks to be approximately some 1:40 long ride. Not many people will want to do that regularly each day.
 
Last edited:
Not just there. Campello gets hosed being in the same city as Brockton and Montello.

I'd do:
Montello+Brockton+Campello - 4
Bridgewater - 5
Middleboro - 6 (same as fellow 495-sited stops Mansfield, Forge Park, Lowell, and Lawrence)
East Taunton - 7
the branches - 8

They're afraid to do it because it would expose all kinds of other inequities on the system, like Kingston in 8 and the Providence Line skipping from 4 to 6, and so on and so on.

But this is completely bonkers. . .
View attachment 61372
2020 MBTA Commuter Rail Fare Study
1742917021397.png
 
Trains were ruthlessly on time as they rolled out of New Bedford on Monday morning, but the punctuality didn’t last. Increased train traffic across the MBTA system caused a series of delays for South Coast riders — for both inbound and outbound trains from New Bedford and Fall River. Delays affected many of the day’s trains and saw some trains lag 20-30 minutes behind schedule by midday.
[...]
Later in the day, both the 10:43 a.m. and 11:53 a.m. trains out of New Bedford faced delays, which the MBTA said were caused by “train traffic” — again with delays extending for up to 20-30 minutes.

Similarly, both of the early afternoon trains from New Bedford faced some delays, meaning five consecutive inbound trains failed to deliver South Coast riders to the capital city on time.
Double-tracking the Old Colony Mainline through Dorchester, Quincy, and Braintree needs to happen.
 

Double-tracking the Old Colony Mainline through Dorchester, Quincy, and Braintree needs to happen.
They knew this was going to happen from Day 1 of selecting the M'boro Alternative, and buried it so nobody would ask questions. Old Colony dispatching was only designed from the beginning of the studies 30+ years ago for Middleboro, Kingston/Plymouth, and Greenbush to operate in perfect balance. OTP was pretty good overall because the lines all had level boarding and automatic doors keeping dwell variances low and because they were preferentially segregated to more-reliable equipment, but when something bad happens it always cascades in a hurry throughout the works and drags down all 3 branches at once. The OC lines were never designed to be weighed down on one appendage by a long-distance branch-of-a-branch operation. Certainly not with no mods to the track layout; even the proposed Buzzards Bay extension aimed to lengthen a couple passing sidings on the Middleboro Line (though obviously it couldn't touch the mainline) to keep things in balance for the somewhat longer schedule. Basic stochastic variability (i.e. random-chance probabilities that something won't time right) can bring the whole system to a screeching halt, even when it's not an *obvious* whopper like malfunctioning equipment. There were a couple spot signal issues yesterday--one on the New Bedford Branch and one in Quincy--but most of the delays were simply cascading for when the dominoes started to fall. I said it in this post last month...the East Taunton shuttles are over-padded on their layovers because they know internally that the OTP of the thru trains is gonna be shit on-the-regular for making the connections.

At least they're talking about the mainline double-tracking megaproject. But it's a little late for that when the brittle OTP for SCR Phase I has been internally known from the start. The sticker shock for the widening project is surely going to keep it from coming to fruition for many more years, meaning we're going to have to put up with the entire Old Colony division being perennially in the gutter for on-time...until they amend the schedule to start gapping out the trains further. :(
 

Back
Top