Having a convention center with easy access to a shopping destination and casino would be an incredible draw for conventioneers and tourists alike. A boon to the hotel industry, restaurants and so on......
thx
Niagra Falls (canada) does this extremely well. It doesn't seem to have much, if any surface parking, is connected to a pretty upscale mall, and didn't feel all that slummy, nor did it appear to bring down the surrounding area.
I think the waterfront would be perfect for a resort casino because
1) there is plenty of open space on which to build, and it would be a boon for the surrounding area
2) as already mentioned, it would be a draw for conventions and conventioneers. Someone also made a good point on uhub that tourists could also be grabbed on their way to and from the cruise terminal.
3) This is key in my opinion: as a completely undeveloped wasteland, future development can be controlled to discourage or completely eliminate the typical crapiness that usually starts to happen around casinos.
The argument that a resort casino on the waterfront would be a waste of space is asinine. A waste of space is to have an area directly accessible to rapid transit (which connects directly to South Station and Logan all in one shot), an interstate highway, three high capacity surface streets and within walking distance to the central business district of the capital of new england house seagulls, parking lots, and a tent for concerts.
Yes, things are slowly being built there but without some kind of landmark (and the convention center alone aint it) this will never be any kind of a destination. At least there will be a real draw to the area that doesn't exist now with a steady stream of tourists coming with the express intent to spend money.
Unlike Atlantic City, which is now and was before the casinos a dump, and the rural casinos, Boston is in and of itself a draw. Just like Niagra Falls, while people will go there to gamble, they will also probably go outside to see some stuff. With any luck it will start attracting more developers to the area and maybe we will finally see something get built. Sure it might be hotels, generic shopping, and other touristy crap, but it would be one hell of a lot better than whats there now.
As for Suffolk Downs / Wonderland, while I agree it seems like a natural fit at first (it did to me), it would most likely wind up becoming a pit. It's not accessible to any interstates, the commuter rail doesn't currently stop there (or connect to any other cities even if it did), and all the roads are over capacity already. Not to mention the area is teetering on the edge just as Atlantic City was. I would love to see wonderland make a grand return with a boardwalk, hotels, and a resort, but a casino wont do it.
Regarding FR/NB, it would be a good location to compete with Foxwoods, as well as grab people from Providence, the cape, and the two cities themselves. Make it a stipulation they have to pay for the T's boondoggle of a commuter rail extension as mitigation, maybe have the casino itself be the train station. Hell, put it in Fall River and make them extend the line all the way to Newport.
Western Mass near Stockbridge would be my choice for a rural casino. You could grab a ton of people from Albany who otherwise aren't going to make the drive, Pittsfield, and Springfield. Make a special exit off the Pike for the casino that charges a modest fee in addition to the regular toll that goes directly into a fund for infrastructure improvements for those west of Springfield.
The slot parlor should go in an already established upscale area (I'm thinking something like Newburyport or the like). In my opinion they are the dirtiest form of gambling. They are addictive, need no skill whatsoever to operate, and (I think) reap the highest profits for the owners. Quite frankly I'm upset this is even allowed, if anything I think that to have gambling it should be required that there be not just table games in addition to slots, but a hotel and entertainment. Anything to keep zombies from throwing their hard earned money into a machine that does no more then eat it at a predefined rate. This is why I think that perhaps if it was in a really nice area there would be less chance for addicts to constantly stream in. However, I fear it was added with the intent to go directly into Suffolk Downs or Wonderland, similar to the "Raceino" they put in at the track in Monticello, NY