Silver Line - Phase III / BRT in Boston

Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

Curitiba has never made their BRT system outrageously expensive by building a tunnel. In fact, their system is operationally financially self-sufficient, with service contracted out to a number of private operators. The Silver Line also fails to fully achieve other advantages of Curitiba's prototype. Outside of the SL tunnel and underground stations, the SL does not have a truly dedicated roadway or a means of fare prepayment.

BRT could be an effective and inexpensive transit mode here if it were more faithful to the Curitiba model. But the SL is a bloated mess that fails to even get the easy parts of BRT right.
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

Boston Globe - May 4, 2009
Silver Line gets money from federal stimulus

May 4, 2009

BOSTON --Gov. Deval Patrick and Mayor Thomas Menino announced Monday they would use federal stimulus money to improve Silver Line service and speed up traffic on the MBTA's busiest bus corridor in Boston.

During a news conference at the Dudley Square T stop, Patrick and Menino said they will add direct Silver Line service from Dudley to South Station. Currently, passengers have to ride to Downtown Crossing and then change lines to connect to the station, which houses Amtrak trains, commuter rail and a second spur of the Silver Line.

The two Democrats also said the existing bus route between the Mattapan and Ruggles stations will be replaced by a high-speed bus route using dedicated bus lanes and priority routing through stop lights.

All told, $114 million will be spent on the projects.

"With smart, strategic use of federal recovery funds, we can bring rapid transit to some of Boston's busiest bus routes, connecting key neighborhoods and delivering reliable service for tens of thousands of commuters who rely on the MBTA," Patrick said in a statement.

Massachusetts is receiving about $8.7 billion under the stimulus bill signed into law by President Barack Obama in February. Lawmakers have been making a series of announcements to highlight the local spending enabled by the law.
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

This is an interesting scheme. I wonder if it means they've finally given up on that insanely wasteful bus tunnel plan for Phase III.

Of course, in an ideal universe, these corridors would be light rail instead of bus, but the T is famously allergic to street-running rail, despite its successful implementation in other cities.
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

I like the priority lighting. That needs NEEDS to go in on the B and C line
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

The new routing is terrible. No more connection with the green line.

Also, they should just rename it.

"Entering South Station, Silver line connection upstairs and then even more upstairs"

Lame.

The mattapan portion makes sense, but the maps show its not BRT, just more of the same "bus lanes" that have as many cars as buses
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

I'm not sure the article implies that the connection to Boylston would be lost, only that there would be a different spur serving South Station. But it's fairly unclear on this point.
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

The Route 28 BRT will have center bus lanes on Blue Hill Ave, which is definitely better than the curb-side lanes on Washington St!
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

From the MBTA's website

Governor, Mayor Announce Silver Line Project

Start Date: 5/4/2009 End Date: Email: jpesaturo@mbta.com

As part of his Massachusetts Recovery Plan to secure the state's economic future, Governor Deval Patrick joined Boston Mayor Thomas Menino and Transportation Secretary James Aloisi today to announce federal stimulus funding to improve bus service along New England's busiest bus corridor and in neighborhoods currently unserved by rapid transit.

The two-stage bus rapid transit project will provide a direct Silver Line connection from Dudley Station to South Station in Boston this fall, and replace an existing heavily-used bus route from Mattapan to Ruggles Station with rapid transit bus service that will provide faster, more reliable service to tens of thousands of trips a day. The announcement comes after the recent announcement of the Patrick Administration "flexed" highway federal recovery funding to build a state-of-the-art regional transit center in Greenfield.

"With smart, strategic use of federal recovery funds we can bring rapid transit to some of Boston's busiest bus routes, connecting key neighborhoods and delivering reliable service for tens of thousands of commuters who rely on the MBTA," said Governor Patrick.

"Improving and expanding our transportation infrastructure is critically important to our economy," said Lieutenant Governor Timothy P. Murray. "Projects like these will not only benefit commuters but also the businesses that count on reliable service for their employees."

"I am proud to support this project because it will revitalize one of Boston's most important corridors and get shovels in the ground and people back to work," said Mayor Thomas Menino. "My administration is committed to helping the MBTA connect our neighborhoods more directly to Boston's financial district and creating more opportunities for our residents."

In the first stage of the initiative, the Executive Office of Transportation will use federal recovery funds to improve Silver Line service with a direct connection from Dudley Station to South Station, including the addition of dedicated bus lanes on Essex Street and a new, state-of-the-art street-level terminal at South Station with lighting, seating, heaters, and countdown signals to provide additional comfort to riders.

Concurrently, a mix of transit and highway federal recovery funds will also be used to enhance service along New England's busiest bus corridor in the neighborhoods of Roxbury, Mattapan and Dorchester. The existing Route 28 bus line will be transformed into first-class bus rapid transit service from Mattapan Station on the Red Line to Ruggles Station on the Orange Line with a direct connection to the Silver Line. Additional station facilities will be located along Blue Hill Avenue in Mattapan and Dorchester, as well as along Warren Street in Roxbury.

This new state-of-the-art bus rapid transit line will also feature dedicated bus lanes, longer "articulated" diesel-hybrid buses, and innovative design and technology features like "queue jumping" (allowing buses to bypass lines at traffic signals) and traffic signal priority to speed up service and dramatically improve reliability. In addition, federal transit stimulus funds will be used to invest in several upgrades to the Dudley Square Station.

The two-stage bus rapid transit project is will cost approximately $114 million, but it could change as the specific design is more refined. Of the projected $114 million, $76 million is for construction and the remainder is for planning, engineering, right-of-way acquisition, and other administrative costs.

"The development of safe and efficient public transportation is a job-creator and an energy-saver," said Senator Edward Kennedy. "This federal investment will mean increased access to downtown and faster commutes for thousands of Massachusetts workers and residents. I commend Governor Patrick for his efforts to ensure that public transportation in Boston and throughout Massachusetts is first-rate."

"This means jobs and economic development in communities that need a boost," said Senator John Kerry. "Faster, cleaner buses mean fewer harmful emissions and a better quality of life for the thousands of Boston residents who rely on public transportation for a safe, quick commute."

"I am pleased that Governor Patrick is using stimulus funding to address the needs of these neighborhoods. When completed, each of these BRT projects will offer better transit to residents, increasing access to employment and other opportunities," said Congressman Mike Capuano.

"These federal stimulus funds will not only create jobs but will dramatically improve bus service, making commutes greener, more comfortable and more efficient for thousands of MBTA customers each day. This is a perfect example of how state and local government can utilize stimulus funds to put people back to work while investing in public transportation," Congressman Stephen F. Lynch said.

"There were 10.7 billion trips on public transportation in 2008, and signs point to even greater use-and need-for mass transit in 2009. These funds will help reinvigorate vital public transit lines just as record numbers of people are choosing to take public transit. This funding is crucial to better mobility, cleaner air, and reduced traffic congestion for the people of Massachusetts," said Congressman Edward J. Markey.

"We are using federal stimulus funds to make a real difference for people who depend on bus service every day, whether it's for work, school or to get to a doctor's appointment," said Transportation Secretary James A. Aloisi, Jr. "With this forward-looking investment we can support economic growth, social justice and create better service for tens of thousands of riders."

"This project builds on the tremendous success of the first phases of the Silver Line by expanding that high quality, reliable bus service," said MBTA General Manager Daniel A. Grabauskas. "This project will also create jobs now, and spur economic development throughout these neighborhoods of Boston."

"Throughout the Commonwealth we are using stimulus funding to create new jobs, fix our deteriorated highways, and support economic development and public transportation to build a better future for our communities," said Governor Patrick's Director of Infrastructure Investment Jeffrey Simon. "In this way we can use short term dollars for long term economic investment."

This transit investment is part of the Patrick Administration's "You Move Massachusetts" civic engagement and transportation planning initiative, which included feedback from transit riders pleading for improvements to slow and unreliable bus service. Over the past few years, the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority has invested in a wide variety of initiatives to improve bus service, including a state-of-the-art control center and GPS tracking on buses to lessen the impact of delays on customers. The stimulus projects will build on those improvements with the "next generation" of bus service.

To learn more, visit: www.mass.gov/eot.


"This new state-of-the-art bus rapid transit line will also feature dedicated bus lanes, longer "articulated" diesel-hybrid buses, and innovative design and technology features like "queue jumping" (allowing buses to bypass lines at traffic signals) and traffic signal priority to speed up service and dramatically improve reliability."

Bull shit. They were supposed to do this with the Silver Line in the first place and never did.

I sincerely hope that this is the MBTAs way of coming to terms with the fact that they couldn't pull off Phase 3. Personally I think this is a fine solution until light rail can be built (when pigs fly.)
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

Oh and if you are worried that they are going to start Phase 3 anytime soon, look at the MBTA's time schedule:

Late 2008 Complete the environmental review document and release it for a full public review, including public comment period. [Has this happened?]

Summer 2009 Complete Extended Preliminary Engineering (PE) and request entry into Final Design (FD)

Late 2010 Complete the FD phase of the project

Early 2010 Be recommended for federal funding from the FTA [Excuse me, what?! This assumes a lot]

Early 2011 Start Construction [LOL]

Late 2016 Silver Line III opens for passenger service [ROFLOMGWTF]
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

This is the exact timetable for the Fall River-New Bedford Commuter Rail. If you change "Silver Line III" with "South Coast Rail" the timetable is almost word for word (even the important dates are identical). almost EXACTLY. what a load. The only difference is that early 2010 is when SCRail is is scheduled to "finalize funding sources." Other than that, the dates and schedule are nearly on in the same.
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

Keep in mind the Phase III open date does not mean the end of construction. As of a few months ago the plan was to continue construction for at least a year after it opens. Arlington, Copley and Kenmore all over again...
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

Eight years and one hundred million dollars for existing articulated buses, some painted lanes, prefabricated shelters, and a few new signal boxes at existing stop lights. Are you kidding me? A group of us with a few grand at Radioshack and Home Depot could pull this together in a month or two!
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

I hope they go with 2 + 1 seating in the new buses. It would go a long way to alleviate the cramped conditions of the current fleet. Though it's too bad Neoplan is out of business. I'm not entirely thrilled with the seating configurations on New Flyer / NABI articulated buses. Instead of the nice forward / backward facing seats of the Neoplans, pretty much every other manufacturer goes for the kneecap and passenger flow destroying inward facing seats

Eight years and one hundred million dollars for existing articulated buses, some painted lanes, prefabricated shelters, and a few new signal boxes at existing stop lights. Are you kidding me? A group of us with a few grand at Radioshack and Home Depot could pull this together in a month or two!

No, that schedule is for the Real SL3. SL1.5 will probably be done by 2012 (can't be sure about that number though).
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

The state of the art street level south station stop is the worst part.

Isnt there a way they could make an incline somewhere into the existing silver line area at south station?
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

Considering all the highway tunnels under the area I wouldn't think so. Building a subway portal in the most congested part of the city is moronic and would only add to the congestion. The whole point of a subway is to divert certain traffic away from the streets. The whole idea of BRT operating in downtown just shows how short sighted the MBTA really is.
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

I didn't think it was possible for this to become so much more of a joke than it was when it first opened.

It's embarrassing to have to point out to visitors/newcomers to Boston (or see them discover for themselves) that the Silver "Line" painted on the subway map is really just a bus.

Consider: London just upgraded the high speed rail line that connects with the Chunnel, routing it in tunnels around and through the city in order to use an underutilized station on the other side of the city. It's also simultaneously building a new rapid commuter rail network to cover the eastern half of the city.

Boston spent $20 billion to bury a highway for a few blocks, and is now incapable of doing the same.

It's not just this city, either. This entire country has a serious problem implementing even the most stripped-down public infrastructure project. Is it the lack of funding? Engineering skill? Vision? All three? Pathetic, in any case.
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

Boston Globe - May 5, 2009
Silver Line will expand, but not all are onboard
Patrick taps stimulus funds for extensions


By Noah Bierman and Meghan Irons, Globe Staff | May 5, 2009

Governor Deval Patrick announced yesterday that he would use $114 million in federal stimulus money to extend the Silver Line enhanced bus service into Mattapan on one end, and connect it to South Station on the other.

Administration officials emphasize that they were using money for mass transit that might otherwise be dedicated to highway projects, a greener alternative in neighborhoods where many residents depend exclusively on buses and subways. The project will require new engineering, planning, and construction for dedicated bus lanes, changes in traffic signals, and fancier bus stops, buses, and stations.

"There are jobs to be had now in building out these projects, and we want these jobs, as much as possible, to come from this community," Patrick said in announcing the project at Dudley Square.

Local residents and community leaders greeted the news with mixed emotions, saying they were happy to have an improvement in bus service on a crowded and lengthy bus line to Mattapan, but sorry there has so far been no community involvement.

Some activists also worry that as the Silver Line grows, the community will lose any hope of a trolley line along the corridor as a replacement for the loss of the Orange Line on Washington Street two decades ago. Although the Silver Line is touted as "bus rapid transit," detractors say it is not much faster than a regular bus in most neighborhoods.

The enhanced bus route to Mattapan on Warren Street and Blue Hill Avenue, which will extend to the Ruggles Orange Line station via Dudley Square Station, is expected to open by 2012, to replace Bus Route No. 28.

"If it's still the same way and it's still buses, the same interference that happens now" between Mattapan and Ruggles, will continue, said Representative Gloria L. Fox, a Democrat who represents the neighborhood.

Representative Byron Rushing, a Democrat whose district also includes parts of the Silver Line, said he was not willing to call the existing Silver Line between Dudley Square and Downtown Crossing "true rapid transit" and challenged Patrick - as well as Boston Mayor Thomas M. Menino and James A. Aloisi Jr., transportation secretary - during the announcement.

"I want to have an announcement with you, Mr. Governor, with you Mr. Mayor, with you Mr. Secretary, when you can honestly say we have rapid transit on Washington Street," Rushing said.

Joyce Stanley, executive director of Dudley Square Main Streets, said the community needs the Silver Line expansion and that light rail is no longer an alternative, because "you would have to take down half the buildings."

The line extension on the other end of Washington Street, which will take the Silver Line to South Station, is expected to be complete by the fall. Opponents of a plan to build a $1.5 billion tunnel to connect the Silver Line to South Station and the airport are hoping announcement of an above-ground alternative means an end to the tunnel.

Aloisi said only that "the tunnel will rise and fall on its own merits." Federal officials have stalled the project because the MBTA is deeply in debt and expects to have an operating deficit of more than $160 million beginning in July.

Aloisi's spokesman, Colin Durrant, said officials do not believe operating costs for the expansion will be significant, because they are replacing an existing bus line. The stimulus money being used to build the line cannot, under federal rules, be used for operating expenses.

Several transit specialists and advocates said that the success of the new expansion will depend on the ability of buses to bypass regular traffic.

The MBTA currently has two Silver Line bus routes that are not connected. The route that goes from South Station to the airport is relatively fast, using tunnels and dedicated lanes.

The route on Washington Street hits traffic lights and is often at odds with downtown drivers who ignore the rules and veer into dedicated lanes. Peter Furth, a Northeastern University professor who has studied the Silver Line, said the current method of giving buses priority at red lights has too many limitations to save riders more than an average of 7 seconds per trip. He said most of the Silver Line's time-saving stems from the increased distance between stops compared to a regular bus route.

The expansion announced yesterday includes areas with dedicated lanes, and some without them. In some areas, buses will have access to exclusive passing lanes, so they can get around regular traffic near stoplights. There will also be attempts to give the buses priority at traffic lights and to collect fares before riders board the bus.

But there are potential hurdles. Riders who get on at Mattapan will have to get off at Dudley Square and switch buses if they want to go all the way to Downtown Crossing or South Station. they will have to switch buses again at South Station if they want to go to the airport.

"If it's not a straight shot . . . then I can't support this," said Michele Scott, a community organizer. "I can't understand why the community did not have a say in this."
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

"Joyce Stanley, executive director of Dudley Square Main Streets, said the community needs the Silver Line expansion and that light rail is no longer an alternative, because "you would have to take down half the buildings.""

Hahaha you're an idiot. I really hope she is just being misquoted.

"Riders who get on at Mattapan will have to get off at Dudley Square and switch buses if they want to go all the way to Downtown Crossing or South Station. they will have to switch buses again at South Station if they want to go to the airport."

Can they do ANYHTHING right?
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

05silver-pgB1__1241515923_3742.gif


From the Globe website. If you look closely you can see the map is condensed vertically.
 
Re: Silver Bus Line - Phase III

Absolutely pathetic!

And why does it take three years and cost $114 million to extend a bus route?
 

Back
Top