Condo proposal caught between old and new zoning wins approval on Addison Street in East Boston
By
adamg on
Tue, 03/12/2024 - 10:32pm
“In an unusual move, the Zoning Board of Appeal today approved a 20-unit apartment building at
141 Addison St. in East Boston even though the BPDA has yet to sign off on the project.
The Zoning Board usually waits until after the BPDA has approved proposals with at least 15 housing units before voting on variances requested for them. But while the BPDA staff closed the public comment period on developer Ricky Beliveau's $8.4-million proposal last October, it has yet to forward the proposal to the BPDA board for a vote.
Beliveau's Volnay Capital has proposed razing the warehouse and parking area now on the site and replacing it with 16 market-rate units and 4
affordable units, with 14 parking spaces in a garage. The proposal calls for eliminating roughly 100 feet of curb cuts, freeing up on-street parking along Addison - and would allow green space and street trees on a lot that is now
completely covered by concrete and asphalt, Beliveau's attorney, Richard Lynds, said at a zoning hearing this morning.
Lynds said the BPDA planning staff is refusing to submit the project to the BPDA board for a vote and is insisting that the proposal be redone to fully comply with impending zoning in that part of East Boston, since Beliveau is completely razing the current building, effectively starting from scratch, rather than adding to it - even though he submitted his plans under the current zoning.
The BPDA board approved
the new Plan East Boston zoning on Jan. 18, but the Zoning Commission, which has final oversight over the city's zoning codes, has yet to vote to replace the current zoning with it.
Lynds said that BPDA staff's seeming effort to put the project in limbo included demanding that the building's rear setback increased from the 20 feet Beliveau proposed - allowed under the current zoning - to more than 33 feet, which would be required under Plan East Boston zoning. He said they also wanted an increase in the side setbacks to 5 feet on both sides from the proposed 3.8 and 3.5 feet, even though the current warehouse building has no side setback at all -as allowed under the current zoning - and to increase the lot's "permeability" (how much of the lot is covered by surfaces, such as dirt, through which rain can pass) to 30% from the 27% proposed. The current lot is 100% covered by asphalt and the building.
Lynds pointed to the permeability issue in particular as an example of how the BPDA staff requirements would let the current warehouse and parking area stay, even though the new proposal would be very close to what the new zoning code calls for - and would be far better than a lot entirely covered by substances from which rainwater would drain into the street, instead of into the ground. Also an improvement, he said: Eliminating a building that now has no setback at all from neighboring lots.
"It's letting the perfect become the enemy of the good," he said, adding complying with it would force Beliveau's architect to completely rework the plans - and ironically would allow a larger building.
While BPDA staff may have gotten used to killing projects by simply sitting on them - as it did for four years with
a proposed charter high school in Roslindale - there is no legal requirement for the zoning board to wait for official BPDA "certification" that it's approved a project before voting, Lynds said...”
https://www.universalhub.com/2024/condo-proposal-caught-between-old-and-new