Next Act Awaits the Wilbur Theatre
As owners put storied hall up for sale, redevelopment seems most likely option
By Thomas C. Palmer Jr., Globe Staff | August 16, 2007
If theater in Boston had a home, it was the Wilbur, on Tremont Street.
With no European pretensions or gaudy features, it was designed to make patrons feel comfortable, modeled after a stately residence on Beacon Hill and offering finnan haddie au gratin on the menu.
Now that home is for sale.
After 93 years of packed houses, laughter, and ovations -- with periods of neglect, flops, months of darkness, and stumbling attempts at cabaret or dinner theater mixed in -- the little Wilbur Theatre is again facing an uncertain future.
Robert S. Merowitz, managing partner of Tremont Entertainment Enterprises Inc., and his two partners are dropping the curtain on his company's two-decade ownership of the Wilbur. They will let someone else determine whether the midsize, 1,200-seat theater can survive in an era of on-demand cable TV, iPod videos, and live shows that are more popular with crowds of 300 than a thousand.
"After all these years, it's time to move on," said Merowitz, a developer who got into show business both to make money and to save a Theatre District treasure.
But small independent owners and producers are challenged today. "It's controlled by all the big guys; it really is," Merowitz said.
The Wilbur's landmark status, however, will protect it from being torn down or drastically altered.
Live Nation Inc. ended its lease on the Wilbur almost a year ago, and now a nightclub, on a month-to-month lease, remains the only life left in a building designed by the foremost theater architect of the time, Clarence H. Blackwall.
There is no asking price, but the real estate firm of Grubb & Ellis Co. has developed a marketing brochure -- it resembles a Playbill -- to present the property nationwide.
"The right buyer is one who will make use of the existing historical and architectural nature of the building," said Philip G. Giunta, senior vice president at Grubb & Ellis.
But the name of the play on the Playbill is "The Investment Opportunity," and clearly Merowitz is looking to cash in on the current smash-hit status of the real estate investment market. His company bought the Wilbur in 1988 for $3.1 million and tried to sell it in the mid-1990s for $3.5 million.
According to city officials, allowable uses include residential, office, retail-restaurant, hotel, and entertainment.
Merowitz said the owners have done well, but acknowledged there have been tough times. After Live Nation's lease expired last year, "The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee" came in and finished the year. "Pretty much since then, it's been dark," Merowitz said.
But back in the day . . .
Built by the powerful Shubert brothers and named for their friend and manager, A.L. Wilbur, the theater was Boston's 10th when it opened in 1914 with Edward Sheldon's "Romance," starring Doris Keane. Mayor James Michael Curley and his family were in the audience.
It had the first lounge in any Boston venue, where patrons could have refreshments between acts, and later restaurants such as Rex, with "Joey and Maria's Comedy Wedding," and clubs, such as the current Aria, occupied the space.
The theater itself, in its prime, debuted shows headed for Broadway. Thornton Wilder's "Our Town" premiered at the Wilbur, and, according to news accounts, audiences walked out on an unknown Marlon Brando in Tennessee Williams's "Battle of Angels" in 1940 -- but came back to cheer him seven years later in "A Streetcar Named Desire."
They were all there: Lillian Gish, the Barrymores, Katharine Hepburn, Hume Cronyn and Jessica Tandy, Jason Robards, Alan Bates, and, more recently, Al Pacino in "American Buffalo" and Quentin Tarantino and Marisa Tomei in "Wait Until Dark."
But a news story in 1994, a tough year for the theater, noted that the "three-story jewel box of a house remains empty and lonely."
Catherine Peterson, executive director of ArtsBoston, a performing arts service group, said it's unlikely the Wilbur will continue as a theater. "It's a near-perfect playhouse for the spoken word, just a gem," she said. "But the days when plays toured the country with their original stars are gone."
So today's real-estate play may mean change -- development -- but that will take some creativity. The Wilbur was renovated in the late 1960s and in the 1980s, and declared a Boston landmark in 1987. A dozen years ago, the city's then-cultural commissioner said: "No one can change the outside of the Wilbur, the color of its paint, its interior, its lobby, the downstairs, or the hall itself."
Although the facade and parts of the interior are protected, the city has been flexible in recent years about changes made to accommodate new uses in historic buildings.
Since the successful shows of the 1970s such as "Hair," "Godspell," and "You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown" struck their sets for good, owners have tried dinner theater -- "Sheboppin" flopped -- and cabaret. They even wanted to bring in a swing orchestra, but local unions shut the place down with pickets.
Merowitz won the prestigious Elliot Norton Award, which recognizes achievement in Greater Boston's theater community, for saving the Wilbur, and Boston's theater neighborhood is now on the mend.
A W hotel is going up across the street, the nearby Courtyard Boston Tremont Hotel has been spruced up, and the old ticket-trailer lot on Stuart Street, next door to the Wilbur, is about to get a glitzy spire of condos wrapped in Times Square-grade neon.
"I would like to see it stay an entertainment use," Merowitz said. "Everyone always loved the Wilbur Theatre because it was such an intimate house."
Thomas C. Palmer Jr. can be reached at
tpalmer@globe.com.
? Copyright 2007 Globe Newspaper Company.