Are you guys joking? Off the top of my head I can think of half a dozen independent coffee shops within a block of this site: Bard, Arabica, HiFi, Burkes, The Works, 88 Donuts...Were you around here when the kids were throwing rocks through the windows of the Exchange St. Starbucks? I know there were a lot of local choices at the time beyond CBD - Bard Coffee cones to mind - but most of those are gone now.
The Middle Street Starbucks shut down because they got out-competed by better coffee places, but I'm sure they'd prefer to blame the people who broke their windows to avoid taking responsibility for being sub-par.