Alien on the park
By Steve Bailey, Globe Columnist | April 11, 2007
If a picture is worth a thousand words, the photo that accompanies this column says far more than anything I could in a few hundred words.
We have spent billions on the Big Dig, years arguing about what will go on the Rose Fitzgerald Kennedy Greenway, and this is what the city has approved to be built on the edge of this alleged precious common ground? Russia Wharf needs to go back to the drawing board for a major overhaul. Even its decidedly mediocre next-door neighbor, the new InterContinental Boston, has sued to block Russia Wharf, saying in part that the hideous 31-story tower will block the views from its own much smaller boring glass curtain of a tower.
The Greenway was supposed to be the kind of opportunity that comes along once in a century. But instead of building upon Boston -- see the great Norman Leventhal's gracious Rowes Wharf just up Atlantic Avenue for what is possible -- developers and the city are conspiring to give us the look and feel of an off-ramp outside Dallas. Or is it Houston?
Of the InterContinental, the Globe's Pulitzer-prize winning architectural critic Robert Campbell wrote last year: "It's hard to imagine how so much money and talent could have gone into a project so lacking in architectural interest." Bad architecture begets bad architecture. See what the Millennium project has brought to Lower Washington Street.
The problem is our current director of the Boston Redevelopment Authority, Tom Menino, who never saw a big building he would not build. What matters most to him is not what it looks like, but what kind of dough it will bring in for the city.
Peter Meade, chairman of the Greenway conservancy, was one of many shocked when he saw a picture of Russia Wharf in the Globe . "I didn't see that building as an asset," Meade says. The BRA is already back pedaling. Says spokeswoman Susan Elsbree: "That was not the design that was presented to our board."
Russia Wharf was designed by CBT/Childs Bertman Tseckares Inc., the state's second-largest architectural firm. The $300 million-plus office tower and the three existing low-rise brick buildings to be redeveloped as condominiums were recently bought by Boston Properties. Pick your own image, but the CBT design looks to me like something out of "War of the Worlds," an alien ship landing on a building, totally foreign to its surrounding.
If you, too, are appalled by the CBT design, consider this: CBT is now in charge of designing Steve Belkin's 1,000-foot tower downtown, the one that renowned architect Renzo Piano would not put his name on. Imagine the possibilities if you dare.
CBT and Boston Properties would not comment.
It's not too late to fix Russia Wharf. Think Hotel Commonwealth. Four years ago the Kenmore Square hotel was built and opened when there was a neighborhood uproar over the tacky fiberglass exterior. The BRA made the owners spend $5 million to upgrade the materials. It is not great, but it is better.
Can we not aim higher on the Greenway?
Steve Bailey is a Globe columnist. He can be reached at bailey@globe.com.
Link
He's picking the wrong battle. And what is wrong with MP? It seems Steve has a problem with glass.
I think we should email Steve Bailey with complaints about Joe Fallon and and see if we get anywhere.