General MBTA Topics (Multi Modal, Budget, MassDOT)

Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

My first question is so some of it is suburban congrats why would it make sense to have most of the land area in a city be suburban. It still leaves the issue arlington mentioned of suburban interests having too strong a pull.

What I was suggesting which is a bit different from you is not a county government but a true expansion of Boston's city boundaries to route 128 roughly speaking not necessarily that arbitrary but it gives a good approximation of the boundaries.

QVuGAhl.jpg


This overall looks pretty exurban yes there is an urban/suburban pocket but most of it is very spread out housing developments and individual homes scattered around with a few retail/office strips. I don't know what else you want for exurban yes some areas especially headed out towards Worcester are urban/suburban but even this is very spread out unless you are in Framingham and marlborough.
zj0ObuK.jpg


All you really did was highlight that Boston's suburbs are build as islands of urban areas surrounded by super low density development that has completely different outlooks on what is important as far as transportation is concerned.

I don't disagree with all your ideas a lot of them are good but the boundary you are drawing seems too broad to me to truly achieve what arlington had been describing.
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

Let's also remember that reaching the 10-mile mark from Boston (essentially 128) has been the goal underlying all planned rapid transit extensions since the 1910s. If we ever move to a Metropolitan Transit District with greater autonomy from the legislature than today's MBTA, we're going to 128. Perhaps it makes sense to establish two financing regimes for CR and RT, as they serve different constituencies, but otherwise it's 128 or bust.
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

Let's also remember that reaching the 10-mile mark from Boston (essentially 128) has been the goal underlying all planned rapid transit extensions since the 1910s. If we ever move to a Metropolitan Transit District with greater autonomy from the legislature than today's MBTA, we're going to 128. Perhaps it makes sense to establish two financing regimes for CR and RT, as they serve different constituencies, but otherwise it's 128 or bust.

Cantab -- I think the real viable route is Metro County government

Increasingly, the Boston Metro Area [broadly defined to include Lowell] economically is separating itself from the rest of Massachusetts outside of Worcester and binding itself to Southern NH and Providence RI and the bit of Maine up to Portland

This is apparent on Nighttime Satellite photos, weather forecasts, etc.

However, there is no governmental structure smaller than the state that can appropriately deal with the relevant issues except for the alphabet soup of agencies that while they say Mass this and that - -they really mean Grater Boston ....
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

Is the T getting better?

Today's Herald quotes a new report on cancelled trips that paints a mixed picture -- Note the period in question includes the Great Snow of 2015

Bottom Line more trips have been cancelled so far this year -- -- than the same period in 2014

34,347 trips cancelled so far this year, compared to 30,287 during the same period in 2014, an increase of 13 percent.

Broken equipment-based cancellations down
The report showed the agency is doing a better job maintaining its fleet, and trips lost to disabled vehicles improved from 4,329 to 4,052.

Missing and AWOL driver caused cancellations UP

However the majority of lost trips were caused by employee absences, which were responsible for 
68.7 percent of lost trips in 2015, an increase of 1,554 over the prior year.
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

Note the period in question includes the Great Snow of 2015

Which makes the entire analysis bogus and the article disingenuous. We all know about the problems of winter 2015. If we want to understand the current state of trip cancellations, the data needs to be from a period after the T was fully recovered. Say, May forward, 2015 vs 2014.
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

Which makes the entire analysis bogus and the article disingenuous. We all know about the problems of winter 2015. If we want to understand the current state of trip cancellations, the data needs to be from a period after the T was fully recovered. Say, May forward, 2015 vs 2014.

chmeee -- No -- it just means you need to have more data for the full picture to emerge -- this is only the first of what I'm sure will be an on-going series of such analyses

While the Great Snow certainly contributed to both vehicle, ROW and even driver absences -- there were plenty of days in the Winter period when the streets and other fixed elements of the transportation infrastructure were able to be used as they are typically used in the winter

For example -- There was almost no snow from the start of the traditional winter season through most of January

If those similar periods saw fewer or more absences of drivers that is an interesting and potentially significant observation
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

For example -- There was almost no snow from the start of the traditional winter season through most of January

If those similar periods saw fewer or more absences of drivers that is an interesting and potentially significant observation

That would definitely be an interesting observation. Like I said, the Feb/March period needs to be split out so we can understand what happened then versus what happened when ops should have been normal. This does not provide that as far as I see. I'd need more time to read to be sure though.
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

Just to put in context: There's been something approximating 2.7 to 3.0 million trips in the first nine months of this year.

30,000 cancelled trips is about 1%.

Pretty good if you ask me, considering all the shit that can go wrong.
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

The MBTA is effectively bankrupt. It should be shut down completely then just completely re-constituted brand new within the state constitution and begun again as a brand new company "MBTA 2016 Ltd." Cut out all the waste, more oversight. Just start over brand new.
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

Let's also remember that reaching the 10-mile mark from Boston (essentially 128) has been the goal underlying all planned rapid transit extensions since the 1910s. If we ever move to a Metropolitan Transit District with greater autonomy from the legislature than today's MBTA, we're going to 128. Perhaps it makes sense to establish two financing regimes for CR and RT, as they serve different constituencies, but otherwise it's 128 or bust.

That's what the point of the MBTA'S Advisory Board is/was.
http://www.mbtaadvisoryboard.org/about-us/

(Quote)
The chief elected official of each of the 175 cities and towns in the district, or his or her designee, is a voting member. Each municipality has one vote plus fractions of votes equivalent to its weighted proportion of the deficit (Chapter 161A, Section 7A). As assessments change, so does the precise weight of each municipal vote.
(End Quote)
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

That's what the point of the MBTA'S Advisory Board is/was.
http://www.mbtaadvisoryboard.org/about-us/

(Quote)
The chief elected official of each of the 175 cities and towns in the district, or his or her designee, is a voting member. Each municipality has one vote plus fractions of votes equivalent to its weighted proportion of the deficit (Chapter 161A, Section 7A). As assessments change, so does the precise weight of each municipal vote.
(End Quote)

I think what we were describing was a transit district not beholden to General Court authorization for capital budgets. There's municipal participation in all the regional bodies, MPO, MAPC, MBTA, etc... but there's no real power at a municipal level to effect any meaningful change - no significant revenue raising capacity, tepid inter-town cooperation, the advisory board was solidly in line with that system, which is what we're arguing needs to be revamped moving forward.

As it is, the money flows to the State, and therefore it's Beacon Hill that is the primary actor concerning the MBTA. We're just sketching an unrealistic proposal for what an autonomous agency - with muni participation and greater revenue capability - could accomplish and where the limits should be drawn.
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

It's nice that they're going to reinvest the proceeds from selling this art into new artwork for the station.

http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/20...onic-murals/shs5VgfMaBHIJYtfsF46BP/story.html

MBTA tracks down artist who created iconic murals

By Malcolm Gay
Globe Staff
September 18, 2015

It was like a crowd-sourced manhunt, but for an artist.

“The #MBTA would like to return #GovCenter artwork to artist Mary Beams. Are you or do you know the artist?” transit authorities tweeted last summer.

At stake were 19 murals Beams created for the T’s Government Center Station in the late 1970s that had achieved near iconic status during their 35-year residency. Transportation officials had removed the paintings in advance of the station’s overhaul. Now they wanted to return them to the artist, but she had vanished, like so many dreams of an on-budget Green Line extension.

“I got a phone call one day,” Beams explained, “and a voice I didn’t know said, ‘How does it feel to know that all of Boston is looking for you?’ I had no idea what to say.”

Beams, it turned out, hadn’t disappeared at all. An animator who had been a teaching assistant at Harvard’s Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts, and whose work has been collected by the Museum of Modern Art, she’d simply left the art world, devoting herself instead to baking pies on the shores of Lake Superior. A part-owner of the Pie Place Café in Grand Marais, Minn.,Beams will be returning to Boston, where next month, with her blessing, the MBTA plans to hold an online public auction of the artworks, giving Bostonians a chance to own a piece of the city’s history.

“The paintings themselves are very exciting,” said Elizabeth Haff, a specialist in American and European artwork at Skinner Inc., the auction house handling the sale. “When I first saw them, I had the feeling you get of glimpses as you do when you are in a car.”

Rendered in Benjamin Moore house paint on plywood, the murals have a strong graphic quality reminiscent of silk screen, depicting quintessential Boston scenes of trolley cars and commuters. Beams created the works by taking film and photographs while riding the T, images she and her staff of volunteers later traced and painted on the plywood.

“I’d put anything I felt like putting, so in one window you might see giant hands holding giant newspapers, and then in the next you might see a group of people playing with a dog,” said Beams, 70, whose break-out creation this season is bumbleberry pie, a confection of blueberries, raspberries, strawberries, and rhubarb. “There were a couple where I threw all my friends in and made them do silly things.”

The murals initially were intended to be temporary. But the MBTA never removed them, and after 35 years in what was the T’s biggest transit hub, the murals have been seen by millions of commuters.

They’ve also collected their fair share of grit. Though the MBTA installed plexiglass covers to protect the works in the late 1980s, some of them have suffered water damage.

Auctioneers say they initially considered conserving the murals before the sale. But the house later opted to sell them as is, with, “you know, grime,” as Skinner specialist Mike Moser put it.

“This lends some authenticity to it: You might as well have some brake dust,” said Moser, who specializes in fine wines but is helping to coordinate the sale. He added that the murals are actually in remarkably good condition after having spent the better part of four decades underground in a subway station.

“It’s house paint, so you could probably — I’m not advocating this, and I’m not a conservationist — but you could probably just take a wet paper towel and wipe them off.”

Skinner estimates that the murals, many of which measure 4 feet by 8 feet, will bring anywhere from $800 to $3,000 per lot. One thing that makes the sale different, however, is that Beams made paintings only rarely, sold very few of her works, and has no auction history to speak of.

“It certainly is unusual,” said Haff, who said that Skinner’s valuations of the paintings are based on their “visual appeal, which is very good, and on their historical context and their importance to Boston.”

The MBTA said it had initially considered placing the murals elsewhere — they couldn’t be reinstalled in the renovated Government Center stop, because they were no longer up to code — but couldn’t find a location where they’d be protected from the weather. When agency officials finally located Beams, they offered to return the murals. Her response: “Heck no.”

Marggie Lackner, the MBTA’s director of design and architecture, said they discussed selling the murals at auction and placing a porcelain enamel panel of the images in the renovated station. “Mary thought that was a good idea,” Lackner said via e-mail. “She said she thought it might be good for a new artist to have a chance to have their work there.”

The MBTA now plans to use proceeds from the sale to create the commemorative panel, with remaining funds going toward new artwork for the revamped station.

The online auction and display of murals will run Oct. 20-29, with a kick-off event at the state Transportation Building at 10 Park Plaza on Oct. 21. Posters drawing attention to the sale will begin to appear by the end of this month.

The event will be something of a homecoming for Beams, who left Boston soon after completing the murals. She has never been back.

“I am so curious to see them again,” she said. “I’ve gone on and lived this whole other life. But to be able to confront something that you made 35 years ago and ponder what they’ve been through? It’s quite amazing.”
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

There are very few things i like more than the history of art in transit stops. this story takes the cake.
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

The unintentional comedy level is very high
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

they couldn’t be reinstalled in the renovated Government Center stop, because they were no longer up to code

What code would they be in violation of? Anyone have any idea?
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

Fire code I bet.
That's what I assumed, particularly when they said that one alternative would be to clone the paintings as enamel-on-steel. I read that as confirmation that the problem wasn't size or clearances, but materials: housepaint on plywood.
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

What code would they be in violation of? Anyone have any idea?

Fire code, mayhaps? I assume the stipulation is that you can't just have canvas lying around in an enclosed underground space.

Regarding this thought exercise about a transit district/metropolitan government, I'd love to blow it up outside of the echo chamber of this thread/ArchBoston. Would anyone like to speak more seriously about this at a charette-style Beer & Transit event sometime in the coming months?

Supporting ideas like this is precisely what I want to be advocating for with TransitMatters and connecting those ideas with other advocacy groups, municipalities, and the general public. We basically can't make any headway with better regional transit without significant amounts of work to overcome the parochial approach of city-by-city transit planning.

We really can't afford to keep having these one-off conversations with municipal DOT heads who are either over-worked or stuck in a 1950s-era planning mindset. I ran into Chris Dempsey on the 66 the other day; as a member of the Brookline Transportation Board, he noted that the former reason has been why Brookline hasn't completed the Green Line Transit Signal Priority traffic study since the update last summer (an issue in and of itself). Which reminds me...I need to bother him today to see if he can report any updates on the status of that study and/or TSP on the C train.
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

Yeah. In hindsight, that's pretty obvious. Thanks.
 
Re: Driven By Customer 'Service' Parte Dos

Some recent happenings on the T:

Last Week

Bomb threat cited for Orange Line delay

Orange Line service was delayed Wednesday morning as transit police spent about 20 minutes interviewing witnesses and searching for a man who allegedly made verbal bomb threats while on board a train. The southbound train was stopped at Back Bay Station.

MBTA spokesman Joe Pesaturo told Boston.com that a suspect was taken into custody shortly after noon.

...

Seems like the situation was handled as well as possible. It's a shame that incidents like this can snarl everyone's commutes.

---------------------------------

Brawl between MBTA officer, woman under investigation

A violent scuffle between a Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority officer and a woman on a bus is under investigation after the altercation was caught on camera.

The lengthy video shows the transit officer struggling to hold on to his baton before he pulled his gun on the woman.

"I was maced, hit with the baton and he pulls a gun, so that's stupid," Shelisa Bittle said.

...

Sad situation. This happened on the 15 bus. I'm pretty sure that's the same route that was in the news for the altercation between the driver and passenger a couple weeks ago. The 15 bus getting in the news for all the wrong reasons. That's a key bus route that serves a large population of people. Too bad that passengers on a major bus route have to put up with these types of situations.

---------------------------------

Last Weekend

MBTA drivers will compete in a ‘bus roadeo’ this weekend

It’s going to be a big weekend for MBTA bus driver Tyrell Sullivan.

Sullivan, a Roslindale resident who drives the Route 73 bus between Harvard Square and Waverly Square in Belmont, is the reigning champion of the T’s annual bus roadeo. The 39th edition will be held Sunday, at the MBTA’s Charlestown bus yard.

“I’ve got to defend my title,” said Sullivan, a two-time champion who also won in 2010.

...

Pretty cool. I like to see bus drivers take pride in their job. They do not get enough respect, in my opinion, even if they may be over paid - but that's a different story for another time. I wonder if "roadeo" success translates to good performance on their actual route.

---------------------------------

As Summer Fades, The MBTA Prepares For Winter

It’s almost 90 degrees on a Sunday afternoon. There’s barely a cloud in the sky and crews out here on the stretch of the Red Line between JFK/UMass and North Quincy stations are working without any shade in sight.

...

Crews are in the process of repairing crucial elements of the MBTA that failed last winter. On the Red Line, the big problem was 40-year-old third rails (power sources for the trains).

...

All of this work is being done on nights and weekends as part of the governor’s nearly $84 million Winter Resiliency Plan.

...

I hope this work is reflected in T's performance this winter. I'm glad they are doing something, but it may be too little too late after deferred maintenance for so long. At least it's better than nothing. Cross your fingers and hope for a bearable winter without a complete shutdown of T system.
 

Back
Top