For years, the old Provident nursing home has been just another eyesore on Commonwealth Avenue. Set atop a hill near the corner of Warren Avenue and Commonwealth Avenue, the building has hulked depressingly over a trash-strewn median strip, in the shadow of a medical office building and public housing.
But last week, the community met once again to discuss proposals to turn the depressing old property into something useful and hopefully beautiful. Proposals currently on the table include:
Allston Brighton CDC? A five-story building with four stories of housing and a one-story garage. Eight units would be one bedroom, 23 two bedrooms, and 9 three bedrooms; 21 of the units would be set aside as affordable housing while 19 would be market rate.
B?nai B?rith Housing New England ? A five-story building with 39 one-bedroom units and 13 two-bedroom units; 20 units would be set aside for low-income buyers, 15 for middle-income buyers and 17 units at market rate. The building would draw on the architectural style of buildings in the neighborhood.
Brighton Partnership for Community Reinvestment ? A six-story building with housing on four stories and two stories reserved for a garage. It includes 49 two-bedroom units and eight one-bedroom units. Nineteen units would be set aside for affordable housing and 38 available for market-rate housing. The proposal centers on the beauty of the building and the developer promises funds to clean the disgusting median strip in front of the building, upgrade the nearby park, and even promises .33 percent of every sale to be set aside for the community to use at its discretion.
New Atlantic Development Corp ? Four stories of the five-story building will be used for housing, while one story would be reserved for parking. The building includes three, one-bedroom units, 39 two-bedroom units and eight three-bedroom units. Half of the units will be available as affordable housing while the other half will be sold at market rate. This project focuses on sustainability, and includes plans to retain rainwater and use heat-recovery ventilation systems that are energy-efficient.
I wasn?t at least week?s community meeting, but I think this stretch of Commonwealth Avenue feels dirty and abandoned. There?s definitely a ?yuck? factor in walking down that block. Any good plan will focus on bringing a little beauty to the area. Apartments should be large enough to attract young couples and families, and not just students. More attention should be paid to maintaining and beautifying the street and parks nearby. A really smart use of space would include some retail stores in the mix to increase foot traffic and neighborhood walkability. Mixed-income housing is good, but let?s face it, this part of Brighton is also in dire need of middle-income and professional residents. (Witness how the 300 Allston Street condos dramatically changed the feel of the neighborhood, in addition to providing a very-well-maintained, now heavily used neighborhood park.) I?m not sure that any of the proposals on the table combines ALL of these things, but if I were to choose among them, it seems the Brighton Partnership for Community Reinvestment hits closest to the mark.