Count me in the negative, too. I actually think the Peebles design is good. From some angles the curve is very, very nice, and as others have said, it's probably the best-integrated design of the bunch.
I've got a big problem with what's inside of it, though. There are two (soon to be three) very large hotels just a few blocks away from it, with many more in the surrounding area, and yet it has more than 150 hotel rooms and less than 90 residences. It's a gross reversal of priorities in a city as expensive as Boston. The other two proposals didn't wow me aesthetically, but at least they recognized this reality.
I appreciate the civility and intelligence of this forum, it's attention to things besides the mindless, ridiculous height worship you find on SSC and SSP, but I think the ideal of an "urban sense" can sometimes become, in the face of a housing need as massive as the one in Boston, an unhealthy fixation on an abstraction. We need beds more than anything.