Seeing as the current Downtown Waterfront Public Realm and Watersheet Activation Plan is currently up for completion I wondered if anyone had any comments about the development potential of the James Hook site (although I think the public comment period is over).
Form the BRA planning
document here is the proposal for the Hook site (pages 20 and 21)
Proposals in the Activation plan
1) They are calling for reusing the Northern Ave Bridge as a vehicle street.
2) Looks like the old 200' height remains as the as-of-right.
3) Retail around four sides of the new building.
4) Putting the Harbourwalk below Congress St and Northern Ave.
They refer to a planned renovation of Northern Ave Bridge. I am not sure what this is in reference to, they make it sound imminent, but all I can
see is this Globe reference to the BRA/city planning document. Obviously this doesn't include a likely funding mechanism so I question how legitimate a plan it is.
Perhaps this document was discussed somewhere else not his site, but I haven't found it.
I would not like to see car traffic return to the Northern Ave bridge. The current set-up is not bad, although the planters are stupidly wide considering the amount of per and bike traffic. If all the lanes were open this would not be a problem.
The main goal should be activation of either side. Completion of the
Envoy Hotel will help and hopefully will include a good pedestrian design between it and the Barking Crab. Hopefully the whole Northern Ave stub to Sleeper St is severely closed off to car traffic, a bit like the back of
Harbour Towers (no gates please).
Putting the Harbourwalk underneath the Hook site and Northern Ave bridge seems like a mistake. Although putting it under the Congress Bridge might be necessary. And how about a connection from the south side Harbourwalk at Independence Wharf to Congress St so you don't have to walk all the way down to Atlantic if you are planning to cross the bridge.
On height, I certainly don't have a problem with a reasonably high tower, although perhaps put it on a podium so it does not take the whole footprint. Given the small size I am presuming it will be a hotel or residences. Which I guess means another garage. (Given the prevalence for underground garages on the waterfront, I hope Google designs it's driverless cars to be more like
this though).
I think Hook could be really great if they took the whole ground floor level and made a comprehensive seafood retail / market plus restaurant and cafe out of this.
Perhaps Northern Ave stub next to Hook/Coast Guard could become a public seating with tables plus bikeway and pedestrian access to bridge. Have Hook developers offer 5 garage spots to take away the parking from the Coast Guard.
I would be interested to hear other's thoughts.