I'm REALLY pulling for Eastern Standard to pop back up in some new location, not that it was the greatest of all time but it was local and had good vibes
I second this. I'm of the right age to remember Kenmore pre-Hotel Commonwealth, while still a single young(ish) professional when E.S. first launched. So I share nostalgia for what was there, but also came to deeply respect Eastern Standard. In reading Globe comments., etc., there seems to be this bifurcation of readers into the cranky older folks category who thought E.S. was nothing special and looked back at gritty kenmore with rose-colored glasses, VS. millennials who loved E.S. and had never heard of The Rat. These groups talk past each other, with the older folks particularly perturbed about Hotel Commonwealth in general.
I see it differently. Yes, Hotel Comm. has serious lack-of-character issues, etc., and I wish another design spanned that block. But the H.C. developer is not the same people who ran Eastern Standard. The latter simply did its job extremely well: a very nice, but unpretentious and local-enough experience that was a sure bet anytime you needed it (i.e., friends from out of town, graduation dinner, business meeting, breakfast meeting, cocktails with an old coworker). I am hard-pressed to think of another joint that felt as special, yet wasn't full-of-crap-pretentious, and as decent a value. You just felt good going there. I do not expect this big chain operation that's taking it over to be able to replicate that in any substantive way. In sum., E.S. has nothing to do with old Kenmore/new Kenmore/etc...it was it's own thing, and did it well.
I share Suffolk's hope. There is definitely a place for this kind of establishment elsewhere in the city. Let's hope it's recreated, with original branding intact.